I’m quite sad over the fact that for the last year or so I wake up with tired, puffy eyes almost every single day. This could be old age creeping up on me or the lack of sleep. The Muse likes to think it’s lack of sleep rather than admit she’s getting old.
I’ve set out a quest for over a year to locate the perfect product to de-puff my tired eyes and wake them up again. Sadly, I’ve yet to find a single product that works and believe you me and tried ‘em all!
For the past few months I’ve been using Garnier Skin Renew Anti-Puff Eye Roller and I was kinda hopeful for a while that this would be my solution to my woes. I mean think about it…an anti-puffing agent at the local drugstore for a nice price…seems to good to be true right?


Well fact is that it is too good to be true because it doesn’t work at all. Period. The end. Sad sigh.
Why the Muse was tricked into believing that Garnier Skin Renew Anti-Puff Eye Roller was the solution to life, the universe, and everything is truly beyond her. I guess the Muse was just feeling hopeful that finally some drugstore brand product was finally released that would wow her but sadly as with all drugstore brands she was in for a sore disappointment.
Garnier Skin Renew Anti-Puff Eye Roller comes in a nifty little roller ball applicator and is a cooling liquid that contains a high dose of caffeine. As you may know, caffeine is supposedly a miracle agent for de-puffing your eyes. Personally the Muse has tried many caffeine laden products and none have worked. The Muse likes to think it’s a nice marketing strategy for making us all frenzied about how caffeine wakes up so it should likely do the same with our eyes…not.


Honestly, I should have known the product wouldn’t work from the get go considering that it not only promises to de-puff but also rid my eyes of dark circles. Anything that makes two big promises like that does make me wonder. I decided to try this for a few months before reviewing it so religiously, daily, I’d apply it prior to applying my eye cream. I applied it once in the AM and once in the PM and I almost had myself tricked that I noticed some difference in my eyes…but nope..truly this was a trick of my imagination because honestly the puffiness was still very there.
The product is absolutely ideal as it applies wonderfully well with the applicator. It’s also nice and cooling and has a nice fresh scent. I think the cooling sensation is much of where I got it into my head that the product was actually working however I honestly see absolutely no results in regards to either puffiness or dark circles.
All in all it’s pretty much well wasted but hey what do you expect from a company who makes haircare products right? I’d say stick with the hair products and leave the skincare to the experts.
This Muse is still trying to locate that perfect product to de-puff her tired eyes and she knows now, after many months of use, Garnier Skin Renew Anti-Puff Eye Roller isn’t it!
Skip it! Total trash as far as this Muse is concerned.

Related posts:
- Garnier Nutritioniste Skin Renew The Brusher Gel Cleanser and Garnier Nutritioniste Skin Renew Resurfacing 3-Way Cleanser
- Garnier Skin Renew The Brusher Gel Cleanser Review
- Garnier Skin Naturals Vital Restore Moisturizer Review
- Sue Devitt E-Z Eye Roller Ball Eye Shadow Review and Swatches
- Would You Buy It? Clinique All About Eyes Serum De-Puffing Eye Massage
- L’Oreal Paris Studio Secrets Professional Anti-Dull Skin Primer Review
- L’Oreal True Match Roller Foundation Review and Swatches




{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }
You’re soo right! i bought it too for my under-eye dark circle but NOPE! didn’t work AT ALL. I’m still trying to find a good one that works, since these dark circles really made my life hell. i hope i find a good one soon. Good luck to you too!
hey monika.
in my experience the best defense of all is GOOD concealer
b/c sadly NOTHING works on dark circles sadly
thank you dear *hugs*
have you tried Preparation H?
absolutely not sammy
def not a good idea
try the skinfood eyecare range.
i’ve tried the salmon brighterning eye serum to get rid of my dark circles, however over time guess wat.. dark circles still there but at least its a little bit less. and extra benefits: less puffy eyes & the crows feet in the outer corner of my eyes are definitely softened down.
hi aqua it’s in my to be reviewed pile
I tried the concealer and powder so far and love it
I purchased White Lucent Eye Treatment by Shiseido for my AWFUL dark circles and am loving it so far! =D
hey lina thanks for the rec will have to have a go with it