Which Would You Buy?: NARS Pure Sheer Lip Treatment and Bobbi Brown Treatment Lip Shine

NARS Bobbi Brown

Oh good morning loves of my lives (yes, lives, I have several).

What’s news? Anyone notice some mega beauty trending going on lately? I’ll get into that more later but I see a little trend developing with slim line lippies, yes please, I like those. MAC Slimshine are my FAVORITE slim line lipstick do you think they’ll be back soon since my little eyes spy slime line lipsticks popping up from both NARS and Bobbi Brown.

Which would you buy? NARS? Bobbi Brown?

I swear I needs me some Bobbi Brown Treatment Lip Shine! You know Bobbi does lips right so I have every confidence in the world she’ll create some uber awesome formula with these.

Bobbi Brown Treatment Lipshine SPF 15 ($22) is a lightweight, soft-shine lipstick that doubles as a rejuvenating moisture treatment. It instantly comforts dry, chapped lips and provides long-term moisturization with natural cocoa and shea butters, jojoba, apricot kernel and avocado oils. Peptides, along with vitamin C and paracress, stimulate collagen production to reduce fine lines and wrinkles, while SPF 15 helps prevent future sun damage. Available in 11 shades.

NARS Pure Sheer Lip Treatment and Bobbi Brown Treatment Lip Shine 1

Now NARS follows up close in the heels of Bobbi Brown with the new NARS Pure Sheer Lip Treatment ($25)

NARS Pure Sheer Lip Treatment hydrates, nourishes, repairs and pampers…effortlessly. Buffered with SPF 15 and moisturizing mango butter, it soothes and softens, protecting lips throughout the day. Six subtle yet sublime tinted shades—think mauve, cantaloupe, strawberry, pearl and pinks—caress your lips. Lush and lingering, they’re equally comfortable on their own or underneath your signature NARS lip color. Sexy and safe lips—who said you can’t have it both ways? Available in six shades.

NARS Pure Sheer Lip Treatment and Bobbi Brown Treatment Lip Shine 2

So which would you buy?

NARS or Bobbi Brown? Remember you can only pick one of the two brands, dem be the rules.

I’m with Bobbi! Its cheaper and the variety of colors look way better plus I’m Bobbi’s fan girl anyway so I’m all for it.

Now if we could get MAC to release some new Slimshines I’d be in nirvana.

  • 4/20/10 10:29 dina:

    bobbi – for color :) nars ones look like a yawn!

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 10:31 the Muse:

      dina this is why we’re soul sisters :D

      Reply

  • 4/20/10 10:38 Mimi B:

    OOOh I’m a total Bobbi/NARS fangirl…I’d go with Bobbi though.

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 10:39 the Muse:

      hey mimi :-D bobbi looks like the nicer of the two!

      Reply

  • 4/20/10 11:06 JoElla:

    I am thinking bobbi brown. Love her lip goodies.

    I think Neimans and Saks are both having some sort of sales also.

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 11:44 the Muse:

      yup FF event at Lord and Taylor, Saks, Etc Joella :-D 10% Off cosmetics/beauty and 20% all else w000000t!

      Reply

  • 4/20/10 12:35 Kristina:

    Leaning towards the Nars right now. Likes the sound of Mango Butter. Like the packaging better too!

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 12:38 the Muse:

      ha kristina first one for nars!

      Reply

  • 4/20/10 12:43 Paloma:

    Bobbi…..cuz there are more shades available and it’s cheaper.

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 12:45 the Muse:

      cheaper is always nice paloma :D

      Reply

  • 4/20/10 12:55 Kate:

    Bobbie had me at chapped lips. Seriously anything that provides color to my lips and protects against winter is a winner!

    Reply

  • 4/20/10 13:59 Stephanie:

    I’d go with Bobbi Brown. I am having a mini obsession with the brand right now.

    Reply

  • 4/20/10 14:09 Aimee Pan:

    I’d go for whichever one that has actual pigmentation.

    Reply

  • 4/20/10 15:05 LINDARRAGNAR:

    Maybe its just the packaging but the NARS lippies look so divine like I hate lip products but the pearl colour looks so good D:<

    Reply

    • 4/20/10 15:32 the Muse:

      linda worried about them…the rubber…ew gets gross :D

      Reply

      • 4/20/10 15:47 LINDARRAGNAR:

        typical nars packaging though its always rubber no matter what the product I personally like it cuz if it falls on the ground its ok :D

        Reply

        • 4/20/10 15:54 the Muse:

          it gets dirty so fast though linda….my blushes are NASTY!

          Reply

          • 4/20/10 23:50 LINDARRAGNAR:

            aha muse I took out my blusher (hungry heart) to see the damage and its just glitter city aha

            :( I dropped it once and it bounced saving the product though so I will sacrafice cleanliness for saftey :]

          • 4/21/10 10:14 the Muse:

            aw linda :( try a cotton pad dipped in alcohol :-D I use it to wipe my nars palettes down!

  • 4/20/10 23:13 Kirstie:

    Is both an option?!?! ;)

    I think that I would pick Nars because it is sold at Sephora, whereas Bobbi is not.

    Reply

  • 4/21/10 2:41 Kelly:

    OoooOooh that’s tough! I don’t have any experience with Bobbi’s stuff. I was going to say Nars; since it’s tried and true for me, but I think I’d try Bobbi’s.

    Bobbi’s lippies look more moisturizing in the picture, while the Nars look like they can be a bit on the matter side. Both have lovely colors, but Bobbi has more of a range. I’d love to try Nectarine or Rosy Nude. Hm, I think I have to stick this on my wishlist!

    Reply

    • 4/21/10 9:55 the Muse:

      haha kelly love your excitement :-D quite excited myself :-D

      Reply

  • 4/21/10 7:26 aquahartz:

    Bobbi!! for the colours, formula, packaging aaaannd the price. the whole lot.
    but i might buy NARS later after i have my Bobbi :P

    Reply

  • 6/2/10 14:54 Honor:

    Bobbi defintely so much more choice in colors…. love raspberry pink… and never been fan of Nars lippies

    Reply

    • 6/2/10 15:48 the Muse:

      honor agreed :-D

      Reply

Comments are moderated and won't show up immediately