Sephora Flashy Liner Waterproof Eye Pencil Set Review, Swatches, Photo

Sephora brings together seven of its popular Flashy Liner Eye Pencils in a brand new gift set for $20 ($18 if you’re indulging now with the Friends and Family Event giving you 20% off).

Considering my track record with Sephora Cosmetics this was a hit or miss purchase. I had heard last year from many readers how much they enjoyed the Sephora Flashy Liners but I wasn’t completely sold however offer me 7 of ’em for a decent price and you tempt me easily.


A set of seven Sephora Flashy Liner Eye Pencils with a waterproof formula in a gift set package for $20.

Urban Decay Jackpot definitely gets you more product however it is $39 and doesn’t contain THAT much more than Sephora’s Flashy Liner Set at $20 plus the pencils are considerably bigger here, 0.03 compared to 0.02. So if you’re on a little bit of a beauty budget you can easily indulge in Sephora’s set and save yourself near $20 plus not forsake much formula-wise.

Count me impressed.

Everything about the formula is good plus they seem to last longer on the waterline than Urban Decay’s formula. They have a nice creamy base which blends beautifully, smudges in a snap, and applies without tugging or drama plus color pay off is fantastic as well. I sat around yesterday in Urban Decay 24/7 Eyeliner on one eye (waterline only) and Sephora’s Flashy Liner on the other. Flashy Liner pretty much stuck around clear into the 7th hour stretch where as UD was looking like it needed a little helping hand around the fourth hour of wear. I know many of you have experienced issues with UD’s liners not sticking around on your waterline long so these might be worth a look at if you’ve had such problems.

You get shades Deep Black, Flashy Grey (more like metallic shimmer to me), Flashy Indigo, Flashy Voilet, Flashy Ultra Green, Flashy Ultra Brown (more like bronze to me), and Flash Brown.

Some of the shades come across a normal creamy finish but some have a cool liquid metal effect that gives them a nice shiny gleam.

I’m not partial to all the shades in the set and could have probably done without having both Indigo and Violet and instead replaced it with a cool Gold.

  • Anyone who loves UD 24/7 Eyeliner pencils!
  • Anyone looking for a variety of liner shades in one place (you get seven to choose from).
  • Anyone who likes a long wearing eye liner with a formula that blends and smudges out easily and applies with minimal fuss.

  • Diehard fans of UD 24/7 (you might find some sort of fault with these if you’re a hardcore UD fan, understandable).
  • Anyone wanting a range of cool colors (I felt like I could have done without some of the shades such as the silver and indigo. I’d have liked better shades such as a gold or aqua, room for improvement here).

Overall, the set was a win although I can’t completely verify if they are or are not waterline safe as of yet but so far no irritation on my part. I love the set and thought it was a great deal for the $16 I paid (I got it with the 20% Off Sephora FF). It’s alot to say considering my dislike of Sephora’s makeup quality but when they get it right, they get it right so damn well!

Totally a hit.

Worth your buck and Muse Approved for purchase!


This product was purchased by the Muse for review purposes.
Read my full disclosure statement here.

  • 10/27/10 20:07 Heather / Eyeconic:

    I know Sephora products are hit and miss, but I have this liner in the brown shade and I love it. I have another type of Sephora liner too, and it’s really great as well.


  • 10/27/10 20:33 mon:

    Haha, yay you finally got them! See, I told you they were great right? I bought the flashy liner set that came out last year (same price, same # of pencils, diff colors) and wasn’t sure if I wanted this year’s set but now that I’ve seen your swatches, I guess I’ll just buy the green by itself. Thanks! A lot of the flashy colors are dupes of 24/7s so I have both flashy liners and 24/7s in colors that they’re aren’t dupes for. So much fun!


    • 10/28/10 14:09 the Muse:

      mon you and your army of minions convinced me ;-D such a great value! thanks!


      • 10/28/10 23:27 mon:

        Yay for makeup minions!!!


        • 10/29/10 13:41 the Muse:

          ha mon ;D


  • 10/27/10 20:33 Misato-san:

    oh, I saw this set today and I was wondering if it was worth trying… I guess I have my answer now 😀


    • 10/28/10 12:54 the Muse:

      misato kinda worth the haul imho ;D


  • 10/27/10 22:41 emily:

    Only *$16* with the FF coupon :).


  • 10/28/10 3:20 origami:

    Thanks for posting this!

    I’d be really interested to see these colours swatched side by side with the UD liners that seem to be so similar. For instance: The green looks like UD Graffiti, the silver like UD Dime, etc. 😀


  • 10/28/10 8:24 Promise:

    Do you know if these are made in China? Thanks!!


    • 10/28/10 9:15 the Muse:

      I’m not sure promise sorry. tossed the box out.


    • 10/28/10 23:28 mon:

      My liners from last year’s set say made in Germany. hth


      • 11/2/10 20:09 Promise:

        Thanks, mon!!


  • 10/28/10 9:13 Makedonka:

    Thank You for the review! I am always on a lookout for good waterproof/long lasting liners in the more convenient pencil version (BB rocks the world with her gel liners of course but pencils can be more handy to have around).


    • 10/28/10 9:55 the Muse:

      I agree makedonka ;-D pencils are way handy ;D and my pleasure glad it was helpful hun!


  • 10/31/10 18:42 sarah m:

    these look amazing and great value i have to have these


    • 11/1/10 11:36 the Muse:

      sarah they really are a nice set ;D


  • 11/1/10 18:14 Hazel:

    i’im hellla lovin the violet!


  • 11/2/10 20:27 Promise:

    This is off-topic, but I bought 3 NYX jumbo eye pencils at CVS today! I didn’t know they started carrying them!!! lol


    • 11/4/10 12:51 the Muse:

      yup promise ;-D I’ve seen stuff at cvs lately too!


  • 12/6/10 21:13 Promise:

    Is the green in this a dupe for UD Graffiti?


    • 12/7/10 10:47 the Muse:

      mmm graffiti is a bit more vivid…it comes kinda close?! promise


  • 6/29/12 16:11 Etain:

    Is it just me or is there barely any product in these? I just bought mine and in one use half the tip is gone, and im not sure if there is more product in it or if thats it because i have had liners in the past that only had that much product, does anyone know if there is more product that you can twist up or something?


Comments are moderated and won't show up immediately