March 8, 2013

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen Review & Swatches

This was provided to me by a brand for review but all opinions expressed are my own

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pens

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen may just have put a stop to the search for my HG (holy grail) eyeliner. Don’t get wrong, I’ve run across eyeliners I absolutely love but part of the fun of being a beauty junkie is searching out the very NEXT best thing. But with Endless Silky Eye Pencils in my arsenal I think maybe that search is over.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again THESE are the best eyeliner every and you won’t need another one in your stash once you tried ’em!

There’s a nifty coupon after the jump!

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen

I’ve always been attracted to color eye pencils but I’m kinda disappointed they don’t work out on my waterline. Endless Silky Eye Pens not only work fabulously on my waterline but also my lash line!

These are dreamy and creamy and incredibly easy to smudge. They must be eyeliner choice of the makeup Gods!

Available in ten shades for $15 each don’t hesitate to just BUY them all. Pixi should consider doing some sort of master collection with all the shades, I’d be on board to purchase that.

I’ve been known to rave Urban Decay’s formula but Pixi tops it. The formula is so incredibly creamy it just glides onto lids like a liquid and smudges out flawlessly. They take a second to set but have a budge proof formula that lasts all day on my drier eyes. And the joy is in the waterline peeps because these stick around for a solid few hours on waterlines! Plus the colors (ones without shimmer) show up beautifully on my waterline. I’ve always had issues with colored eyeliners not working on my waterline but not the case with these. Just as an example their black pencil is as richly pigmented as Perversion!


  • CopperGlow

A stunning deep copper with gold glimmer. Absolutely MUST have shade!

  • SageGold

Deep golden green

  • BlackNoir

Intense black

  • BlackBlue

Darkest midnight blue

  • BlackTulip

Deepest glimmering lilac

  • BlackCocoa

Deep brown

  • Deep Plum

Rich plum

  • True Teal

Vibrant blue-green

  • CafΓ© Gold

Soft brown with gold glow

  • Oyster Glow

Light creamy glow

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen Swatches

Top to bottom, left to right: Black Noir, Black Blue, Black Tulip, Black Cocoa, Deep Plum, True Teal, Sage Gold, Cafe Gold, Oyster Gold, and CopperGlow

Pixi Black Cocoa Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Black Noir Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Black Tulip Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Cafe Golden Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Cooper Glow Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen Black Blue

Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen Black Tulip

Pixi Oyster Glow Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi Sage Gold Endless Silky Eye Pen

Pixi True Teal Endless Silky Eye Pen

Colors are pigmented, long lasting, easy to smudge, easy to apply, and have a super creamy formula.

What more could you possibly want in an eyeliner?

With shades like the gorgeous Copperglow to choose from these are hands down the very best eyeliners I’ve tried.

DO get at least one to try!

I bet you’ll be as hooked as I am!

You NEED these.

Muse Approved!

Available at Target,, or grab them online using promo code PIXISHARE to get 20% Off your order and Free Shipping on $50 or more at

This was provided to me by a brand for review but all opinions expressed are my own

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment or follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Bloglovin‘.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Cj

    Omg true teal looks amazing!!! I’ve been really into dark blue eyeliners for some reason lately, pixi has some really nice products! I love the brilliance balms, never tried the eyeliners v4 so deff gonna put an order in, anything else I should pick up wifey?

    • the Muse

      πŸ˜€ these are amazinggggg cj πŸ˜€ teal is gorg ;-D yes fairy dust, Magic Tink Tint, Sheer Cheek Gel

  • Cleo

    Ok – need πŸ™‚ only prob, not in Germany I bet… *ho hum*

    • Cleo

      Ah… but they are from the UK πŸ™‚ Now that makes me a happy chickette!

  • Vi

    This review couldn’t have come at a better time, since I’ve been looking for a good waterline eyeliner! Thanks so much, Muse!! πŸ˜€

  • Michelle

    These actually stay on the waterline?! I will take a case of each please πŸ™‚

    Love the Black Noir and Back Tulip, not to mention the Sage Gold, Cafe Gold, Oyster Gold, and CopperGlow. Oh what the heck, I’ll take them all.

    • the Muse

      black stays on me for five hours before fading a bit ;-D colored shades it varies from three to four hours ;-D they are SO creamy! you’re going to love ’em! Copperglow is a MUST! It’s such a unique shade!

  • Caitlin

    Gorgeous. I want them all except the blues (cause I never wear them), but I especially love Copperglow.

  • Denise

    I just bought Black Cocoa yesterday, and it’s *love*. <3 The Black Blue looks awesome too, because it's different that any other eyeliner shade I have. CopperGlow looks amazing ~ that will definitely be a must-have for me. Oh who am I kidding, they all look like must-haves! I just may have to make it a ritual to buy a new shade every time I make a trip to Target! Thank you for the review and gorgeous swatches! You rock, Muse!

    • the Muse

      YAY denise so happy to hear it ;-D look through the comments someone posted a great coupon if you are purchasing at target!

  • tiffany

    My teal is dried out πŸ™ I have even capped it very tightly πŸ™ very sad! such a stunning color too, so I will be replacing it!

  • Olivia

    These are great shades- I have 3 of these liners and they’re great.

  • Simone

    Thank you so much for posting this! These do not get NEARLY enough attention from the beauty world!

    They are my HG liners as well! *still need to pick up Copper Glow!!

  • Laura H

    I really want oyster gold, I think it would look great on the waterline !

  • Flavia Signori

    So pigmented *0* I love them all <3 And… OMG! I didn't know that PIXI ships worldwide O_O Time to have fun!


  • auroragyps

    I have Cafe Gold liner & I really like it. It’s such a pretty paler shade of shimmery brown. I’d definitely get more colors in the future.

    PS: Gotta thank you Muse, because I won the big Pixi giveaway they had around the Holidays and I think I found out about from your sire. So thanks so much for the post & your awesome blog. I got so many amazing things from Pixi in the giveaway and I think I love just about every item I got. May favs are the liner I mentioned, Tinted Brilliance Balm in Magnific Mauve (the cap is loose, but I put some clear nail polish on the pencil to make the fit more snug), Succulent Lip Twin in Opal Orchid, Flawless & Poreless Primer, Shade Quartette in Shades of Taupe (goes so well with Cafe Gold), and Beauty Blush in Rosy Rouge (which is my totally favorite Pixi thing of all… amazing quality & the color is perfect for my pale skin). Thanks again and keep up the great work. πŸ˜€

    • the Muse

      oh wow auro that’s awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!! sounds like a great bit of products you got there ;-D amazings! so happy to hear it!

  • Melody

    Oh wow! CopperGlow.. I have nothing like it! They’re all so wicked gorgeous!

    • Melody

      *cry of frustration*!! Like Susan said below my Target is consistently out of the colors I want most (especially CopperGlow)
      Say did you try the Kat Von D Starry Eyes autograph pencil set? There’s a shade, Napolitano, that looks similar to Cafe Glow but maybe a bit darker.. it’s mini so I think I’ll get Cafe Glow anyway! πŸ˜‰ Also, do you recommend True Teal for grey/blue eyes?

  • Susan

    Thanks for posting the 20% off code and the swatches! Been wanting these for a while and they are never in stock at my Target. Especially like Copperglow and cafe gold! πŸ™‚

  • Gracie

    Thanks for the review! How do these compare to the Bobbi Brown longwear gel eyeliner pencils?

  • Rory

    Ooh these look fantastic! Do you know how similar Sage Gold is to UD Mildew (my fave UD liner)?

  • Veronica

    I am all over Oyster Gold. I doubt these will stay on my waterline, but I’m always willing to give a pencil liner another try. Besides, this shade is just too pretty to pass up. πŸ˜€

  • Somia

    These are the best -I have them in black, black blue, plum and Black Tulip (my personal favorite) I have a question – have you found a good sharpener for them? They are so creamy (which is what makes them amazing) but my generic sharpener is eating them up. Just curious if you can recommend one.

  • Sienna

    I have three of these (plus a mini black) already, and now I want at least four more. So many pretty colors! Also, for those of you who prefer to shop in-store, I printed coupons from last week for $5 off a $15 purchase of Pixi or NP Set cosmetics. I think it’s still available, and you can print two.

  • christymg

    Save my just-recieved state tax refund, or blow it on eyeliner?

    I mean, I have no plain black liner. No teal. Oyster glow and sage gold are lovely.

    So…I need them, right? And when you need something, it’s a responsibility! πŸ˜‰

  • Phyrra

    I have True Teal and Copper Glow, but holy wow, I need Black Noir, Black Blue, Black Tulip and Oyster Gold.

  • jh

    do you think these will work as well on me if I have super oily lids? πŸ™

    • the Muse

      jh they are ultra creamy so they might be a bit much for oily lids.

  • mj

    I have the one of these that was released with the Fairy collection, and it was instant love! It looks the same as the green/gold one you swatched. It was expensive (for me, anyway, I am a hard core DS only gal) but it is GORGEOUS!

  • Liz Cat

    Oh these are beautiful! That oyster pearl look stunning for brighting an inner corner or even the waterline. Muse thank you for the fabulous review, and bringing Pixi to my attention!

  • Wendy

    OMG I NEED EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THESE! Thank god I get paid this week LOL

  • Cat G

    These are at Target? I must go check them out! Are they permanent? I hope they’re at the one by my house!!

      • Cat G

        Went to Target to pick up four of these today and they were out of Sage Gold AND CopperGlow -the two I was most excited to pick up! They told me to check back in about a week so hopefully they’re there next time I go!


    Now these look like eyeliners!! Thanks for heads up about colorued eye liners which will actually apply to the water line!!!!! Its so frustrating that most eyeliners don’t actually want to stick to the waterline!!

  • Darmowa Bramka

    The pencils look so and girlish with those sweet flowers patterns. I definitely want one!

  • kayla

    Muse, Would you say the Sage Gold shade is similar to the straight on till morning eyeliner released last year?? That was my holy grail green and Its becoming limited online πŸ™

  • Dana

    Are these similar to MAC Pearlglides? I’ve been thinking about picking up some Pearlglides but if these are similar, I might check these out instead…

  • Taryn

    Must have the plum! I love a good plum eyeliner. So often it is too purple for me but that one looks just right. This reminds me…
    Question- I have a plum UD eyeliner that is only a year old but has gotten really hard. I tried resharpening but that didn’t seem to help. Any suggestions?

  • MeggieBeth

    What amazing color payoff, guess I’ll be heading to Target to hand over my next paycheck.

  • melissa

    Golly gosh gee you hit me where i’m weak. I love eyeliners in general. MUFE is my favoriterof the moment but I think I might just grab one or 5 of these next Target spree. TYVM for the swatches and review.

  • Michaela

    I’m pretty happy with my Holika Holika Jewel-light eyeliners right now, but CopperGlow looks like an absolute stunner…

  • Majick

    Well I hope everyone saves a copper glow pencil for ME. LOL THat looks a lot like a Sue Devitt color I used to wear. It was called Gold Reef and it made my amber/hazel eyes look green. I def have my eye on this one.

    Hard to believe they are better than UD… we’ll see. πŸ˜€

  • Pineapple Princess

    I really love all the colors on the bottom row of your swatches! Gorgeous!

  • noemii

    I agree that these are better than Urban Decay! It’s about time someone admits it.. I use Deep Plum Almost everyday in place of basic brown or black. Pixi eyeliners are terribly underrated. i Need copper glow now!!

  • Anne

    ugh at first i was like “i only need the blue” but then i grabbed the champagne and the mossy green and the copper and the dark blue and heck they’re all so pretty!

  • FrΓΆken Frodig

    I probably don’t need any of them…but want them all! Sets nicely on the waterline you say, good for tightlining maybe?

  • Liz

    Is the black comparable to UD Perversion in intensity? Perversion is the darkest eyeliner I have used on my waterline, & I wanna stick with that deep pigmentation. BUT hopefully with a cheaper alternative. =p

  • Samantha

    Just curious, I had major difficulty sharpening mine, how do you sharpen these without wasting product?

    • the Muse

      I’m all about the UD grinder, that thing is total HG for getting pencils to perfect points!

  • Jen

    OMG I just bought one of these off your review – the Teal b/c I was wanting something different and colorful for spring. I’m in love. Let me just say I have oily lids and use primer and so called long lasting gel eyeliners (MAC; BB) and they have nothing on Pixi. I have a crazy teaching schedule and wore this from about 6 am – 10 pm and at 10 pm it looked perfect!

    Thanks for the rec!

  • Jae

    Bad news, these are no longer available in Target stores or

  • Monica

    Love your blog, I’ve been reading it for a long time and now I’m debating which one I should purchase. Would you say the pixi eyeliner is better or mally’s starlight eyeliner is better?

  • Mel

    Have you seen this new one I just snagged at Target called Emerald Gold?! To DIE for go check it out !!!

  • Carla N.

    I. Will. Have. Black. Cocoa.
    I MUST!
    I’d been using gel eyeliner, but have grown disenchanted. I think I’m too fundamentally lazy to fool with a brush. :/
    Pencils seemed to lack pigmentation, but it looks like these don’t!

  • Carla N.

    I got BlackCocoa in the mail moments ago, and I’m impressed.
    It’s a deep, deep opaque dark brown, insanely pigmented and sublimely smooth.
    If it stays on my super-oily lids, I may be erecting a shrine. lol

      • Carla N.

        It *does* hold up well on my oil-slick lids, even without primer.
        I haven’t even tried it “for real,” with primer, powder, eyeshadow, and mascara, so I kind of wonder if I should start looking for shrine components. πŸ™‚
        BTW, another recent eyeliner “discovery” of mine is Physicians Formula Eye Booster, in Deep Brown.
        The latter is a pen-style liquid liner, good for when I want a slightly more intense look.
        Again, no need for primer!

        • Isabella Muse

          Great glad to hear it ;-D!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don’t think I tried the eye booster liner but I love their mascara with the fiber so crazy good ;-D Thanks for the recs! ;-D