December 20, 2010

Mally Beauty Starlight Deluxe Eyeliner Library Review, Photos, Swatches

Don’t quote me on exact times and dates but Mally will be on QVC a few times over the next few days so you might wanna check her out to see if you can grab her sold out Starlight Deluxe Eyeliner Library. I’m not sure if she will have it on and available but it might be worth a Tivo.

Here’s my thoughts on it!

A special set featuring 10, full size Mally Beauty Starlight Eyeliners.

The set comes housed in a sturdy faux leather, pink case. I love the case and think it makes a great choice for storing and traveling with the liners in and hell other liners as well. The liners are all full size so really you’re getting a super deal here. Putting tax and shipping into the total I’m looking at $5 per liner or so.

They have a dreamy, creamy easy to blend formula much like Urban Decay’s 24/7 Eyeliner. They also happen to sport a waterproof formula which seems to wear quite well. I wore them through a bit of snow, a bit of rain, and just generally on an all over eye day and they wore long and strong without running, smearing, or creating dreaded raccoon eyes.

I think the best part of the collection is the sheer amount of variety you’re getting. You got your traditional shades such as brown and black but also other fabulous shades like pink, gold, and black cherry! It really covers a nice range of shades so if your eyeliner wardrobe was lacking a bit of color before this is a great way to amp it up!

Shades include:

  • Midnight (black)
  • Lucky Penny (bronze)
  • Caribbean Sea (teal)
  • Royal Plum
  • Espresso
  • Sailor (navy)
  • Pink Champagne
  • Starshine (silver)
  • Golden (gold)
  • Black Cherry (black cherry)

Out of all the shades my favs are Black Cherry, Pink Champagne, and Golden. Particularly Black Cherry and Pink Champagne stand out the most since they are liner shades you don’t see often or done right.

The finishes vary on the liners but many have a wicked liquid metal look and feel!

I had a bit of a tricky situation trying to line my waterline with some of the shades. Black and brown worked fine but some of the colored pencils just didn’t want to smooth on my inner rim as well as the more traditional shades, not sure why.

  • Anyone wanting a solid performing eyeliner in a variety of shades at a great price.
  • Anyone wanting a formula that wears long and strong.
  • Anyone who loves UD 24/7 Eyeliners.
  • Anyone who wants an eyeliner that glides on sans tugging with a formula that smudges and blends easily!

  • Anyone who doesn’t favor color and prefers more traditional liner shades like black or brown only.

I thought the set was a killer value and I’m hopeful they’ll bring it back with Mally’s next appearance on QVC. It was available for a limited time and sold out so quickly…….I know alot of you grabbed it for yourselves, please do share what you thoughts were about the set! Overall, a really fabulous deal that I’m happy to have in my stash!

Very Muse Approved for purchase (if and when it becomes available again).

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment or follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Bloglovin‘.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Carrie

    Ohh, I am kicking myself for not picking this up! I already have espresso, royal plum and pink champagne and I love them. I need black cherry!!

    • the Muse

      carrie she’s on a few times this week maybe they will bring back!? if I hear anything will post ;D!

  • Laura

    Oh, how I love thee, Muse!

    Do you know if any of the colors are lip-safe? I think the light pink would be a great lipliner, hell even the black cherry if I’m feeling frisky!

    • the Muse

      HMMM good question laura not sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! box doesn’t say anything?! maybe!? but great idea ha!

  • Lucy

    I’ve wondered about these liners. I don’t own any of Mally’s makeup. May be tempted to try her liners. Love the black cherry also. This looks like a great set.

  • Holly

    Is it possible to get the Pink Champagne separate? I usually don’t cheat on my UD 24/7 or MUFE Aqualiners but my eye are straying….

  • Alli

    FYI – I checked out her site and it says that she will be on QVC
    Dec. 31st! Hope she has this set, bc it looks wicked fab!

  • Soo

    oh my goodness, 5$ a liner sounds really good. I really like all the colors too. man! I need to not be broke anymore 🙁