May 25, 2016

Supernatural Rowena’s Makeup Possibly Revealed?

I receive a small commission if you shop through my link.

I was talking on the phone with Dusty a few months ago and we got into a conversation about how fine Rowena from Supernatural looks. If you’re not a Supernatural fan girl or guy you likely have no idea what I’m talking about but for those who are I’m sure at some point you were left wondering what makeup Rowena was wearing. This is particularly the case for her eye makeup because that girl sports some fantastic eyeshadow looks!

At one point, I felt positive she was wearing Urban Decay Mildew Eyeshadow as across a few episodes she had on this stunning sparkly olive green on her eyes that flattered her creamy skin and gorgeous red hair perfectly.

In more recent, episodes you’ll catch her wearing a fuchsia and purple blue look.

I have to admit I’ve mused what Alanna Masterson wore on Talking Dead and Mercedes Mason’s might be wearing but Rowena aka Ruthie Connell beats both of them out with her dramatic eye looks.

If you follow the Darkness aka Amara aka Emily Swallow on Twitter she actually retweets a lot of makeup tidbits about Supernatural. Recently, she disclosed the shade of greige nail polish she was wearing when stroking Dean’s face. Hey, you know you likely had a brief moment where you wish that was you stroking Dean’s fast but the thought was super quickly overtaken by, “OMG THAT NAIL POLISH IS SO FLEEK!”

Up until now mum has been the word on Rowena’s makeup but recently the makeup artist for Supernatural shared a little bit of what might be on her eyes. Looks like Make Up For Ever and Charlotte Tilbury are two names mentioned. Hm..! There goes my theory about Urban Decay!

I haven’t watched the season finale so I’m making the big assumption Rowena is still alive. If so, my master plan is to keep @zabrinamakeup on my Twitter follow list and tweet her every week and ask what Rowena is rocking on her eyes.

This will be my little pet project.

I might just start another blog to document Rowena’s looks because the fandom demands it! Or I’m just a little loser fangirl. One of those two!

Hope there are some other Supernatural fans out there that had a musing or two about Rowena’s makeup too!

I receive a small commission if you shop through my link.

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment or follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Bloglovin‘.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Kelly

    I always love Rowena’s looks. They should post YouTube tutorials for all of them.
    I’d follow your Supernatural beauty blog. I’m a total fan girl. The fact you are too is one of the many reasons I follow your blog religiously.

    • Isabella Muse

      ITA! Or at least an Instagram saying what was used because I swear I sit every episode she is in and wonder what she has on her eyes! Aw thanks kelly <3! I love that I have readers that are not only makeup fans but Supernatural ones too!

  • nskrl

    GURL! Rowena’s eyeliner is always on fleek! I remember watching the episode where she is chained but her eye makeup is still dope! I wonder how she does it

    • Isabella Muse

      Ha AGREED! Girl, looks amazing in all situations 😀

  • Jay

    Interesting! I’ve always wanted to do makeup for a TV show. That may be weird hahaha but its a dream of mine to perfect the characters who look like they’re not wearing makeup. I want to perfect that just-rolled-out-of-bed-but-perfectly-flushed-and-doe-eyed look. TBH I forgot about Supernatural this season so maybe I’ll catch up!

    • Isabella Muse

      oh gosh yes I do want that just rolled of the bed doe eyed look not the puffy I’m tired look haha! Catch up! It’s getting GOOODDD!

  • McRachel

    I have *always* wondered this. Her cat eye is so fierce, my husband even said something about Rowena’s makeup! I’d love to be able to recreate her sparkly green (also thought that was Mildew) but alas, my eyes are very, very round so it may be a bit of a stretch for me. I had been stalking Makeup411 but she hasn’t turned up there. (I thought maybe since Tatiana Maslany turned up there for Orphan Black that maybe I’d get lucky.)

    • Isabella Muse

      right?! She always looks stupid incredible! Her green look was divine!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Darijo

    Just when I thought I couldn’t possible love Rowena even more…

  • Christine

    YES I agree! Rowena’s makeup is amazing! She must have a spell for amazing makeup looks! I LOVED the fuschia look!

  • Monica Hein

    Love Supernatural and Winchester Brother! watching it at the minute : ) Love Rowena and her makeup is on pint!

  • dia

    Yes! I love Rowena. I would totally follow your fan blog. I tried to recreate that look recently but I’m a long way from being as fabulous as her!

  • Kathy Agel

    My husband was so bummed when we thought Rowena was dead a few eps ago. I love her makeup looks — and the way she says “Fergus”.

    We haven’t seen last night’s episode yet — we’re going to watch it after lunch.

    • Isabella Muse

      LOL likewise! Fergussssssssssss! 😀 I didn’t watch yet either, trying to avoid spoilers!

      • Kathy Agel

        I’m bad — I go looking for spoilers. I saw The Force Awakens knowing exactly what was going to happen (and I’m still upset over it) — but If I hadn’t, my reaction in a very crowded theater full of fanboys would not have been pretty.

        • Isabella Muse

          I’m trying to avoid myself 😀 I haven’t been on Twitter or Facebook all day aside from posting on my Musings page 😀

  • Nicole

    Love Supernatural! I will admit this season I will be catching up on when the DVDs are released and I order them. Supernatural was my mom’s FAVORITE show! 🙂
    Her skin and hair are so pretty! The eyes are very dramatic, but what on Supernataral isn’t, so I’d expect nothing less! 😀 Shout out to the IT Cosmetics brush they are using; I guess we are not the only people loving our IT brushes!

    • Isabella Muse

      I couldn’t agree more! Her skin too! She has a gorgeous complexion! Haha! All the It Girls FTW!

  • Carrie

    I love her makeup too, and that there are fellow Supernatural fans on here haha. I’m a bit behind too, but will hopefully be cathing up soon. I also dig her accent 🙂

  • Michelle Maffia

    I have been a long time fan of the makeup artist on Supernatural. I was wondering if you caught on a episode many months ago that to talk to “The dark one”,Dean had a witch use a Marc Jacobs highlighter compact. I knew there had to be other-worldly forces at work with that warlock who goes by Marc Jacobs!

    • Isabella Muse

      Is that the episode where they broke into the beauty parlor!? 😀

      • Michelle Maffia

        I’ll have to check. I remember the boys were interrogating in a police station “party girl” lookin’ witch.

      • StrGazr04

        No that was the episode where Rowena does a spell at a restaurant to kill the waiter and make all the tables and chairs pile up on themselves as a blockade so she can escape. Dean and Sam capture a novice witch Rowena was recruiting for her mega coven and talk to her at the police station. They get her to do a spell to locate Rowena and she uses the mirror in a MJ bronzer compact (you know the massive one?) to do the spell. It made me laugh because at first I thought Dean was going to snap the mirror off and I knew how much that bronzer cost!

        • Isabella Muse

          OH YES YES YES! Now I have to rewatch that eppy lol!

  • StrGazr04

    I have always tweeted requesting that the MUA on set do IG or YT tutorials. You should do blog posts where you recreate looks from the show. Rowena, Abaddon, etc. So many characters with great makeup looks.

    • Isabella Muse

      I would totally watch videos of her doing any makeup on the characters;D

    • Isabella Muse

      Ha I dunno, it was from OPI but I don’t recall the shade. I’m so not a nail girl! If you look on her account and scroll back to last week you should be able to find her tweet!

  • Zovesta

    Not so crazy about SPN now (why couldn’t we have let a good thing die gracefully 🙁 ), but I do love Rowena and her makeup looks! =D Thanks for the post, Muse!

  • Yasmin Carter

    OMFG trying to avoid spoilers because I am crazy behind but I need NEEED to know what Amara’s nail polish color was please help!

    • Isabella Muse

      Oh I wish I knew! I can’t remember the shade she said! If you tweet her she’ll likely reply with an answer 😀