September 28, 2017

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipstick Review & Swatches

I purchased this item and I receive a small commission if you shop using the links in this post.

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipstick ($6.95) are a new, limited edition lipstick formula that launched with Physicians Formula 80th Anniversary Collection earlier this Summer.

I have to admit I can’t recall the brand every having carried lipsticks aside from the Happy Booster Glow & Mood Boosting Lipstick which were more like a lip balm than a lipstick. Anyone old enough to remember Physicians Formula Lipstick?

If you’re a sensitive user these might be of interest to you as they contain no fragrance and apparently the ingredients are hypoallergenic which makes them unlikely to cause any allergic reactions.

Let’s have a look!

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipsticks are fairly affordable at $6.95 a shade. Each lipstick is 0.14 oz in size and comes in a lightweight silver barrel with a clear cap. There’s a pretty floral design that wraps around the barrel and gives it a vintage-y 1950s drugstore feel. Sadly, there are two major flaws with the design of the lipstick and packaging one of which is the fact that the lipsticks don’t swivel all the way down. As you know, this is a pet peeve of mine. It’s very difficult to replace the cap sometimes without slicing off a chunk of the lipstick. I prefer lipsticks that swivel completely down. The second issue I had isn’t necessarily a packaging flaw but a design one. The lipsticks are a triangular shape that at a glance seem easy to apply but in reality are quite messy. I can lay the flat side against my lips and apply color easy enough but the darker shade I purchased, Red Rouge, was impossible to apply like this. I couldn’t quite get inside the lip line and color kept migrating outward. The shape of the lipstick is a bit awkward and messy for me. I also swiveled the lipstick up a touch too far (and I really mean a TOUCH) and it snapped at the base.

I was pretty excited about this formula because it swatches really slick and had a glossier finish on my arm. On my lips the texture is much different as is the finish. The formula is lightly creamy with a fairly easy glide on my lips and a semi-satin finish on my lips. It didn’t tug during application and applied fairly easily although the shade Nude Chair wasn’t as smooth as I had hoped and fell into my natural lip lines without seconds of application. Red Rouge was the smoother of the two but also, apparently the more difficult to apply as the color kept migrating around my lower and upper lip line. But I blame the odd shape of the lipstick for that issue. I think the texture is nice. It’s lightly creamy, has no fragrance or flavor, and it wears for a solid six hours. However, I struggled with application a little on certain shades and also, issues with the color falling into my natural lip line.

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipstick (Red Rouge and Nude Chair)

Physicians Formula Nude Chair Hypoallergenic Lipstick

Physicians Formula Red Rouge Hypoallergenic Lipstick

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipstick has great potential but sadly, as it is, the formula and packaging has numerous flaws that are hard to overlook. I really wanted to like these but the shape of the bullet, the packaging, and the application didn’t thrill me.

Physicians Formula Hypoallergenic Lipstick are available now at drugstores or at amazon.com.

Tried them?

Do share!

Save

I purchased this item and I receive a small commission if you shop using the links in this post.

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment.

Leave a Comment

Comments

  • kjh

    Nah, too fussy for me. I am old enough, but don’t recall any lipsticks from PF. Def never had any. Checked the ingredients. I’m not allergic to any, but wonder what lipstick ingredients, beyond using carmine, are likely to cause reactions. The only one I seem to have a problem with, and it’s minor, is Nudestix. They sting for a bit, not in the plumping way. And they ball up wickedly, at least on the magnetic matte formula. It might be ferric ferrocyanide…nice name, right? One of the color index (CI) shades that they list on Cosdna. That’s the only iffy ingredient in Nudestix. I don’t have any other products that use ferric ferrocyanide, per their list. It is approved for cosmetic use. Think I’ll see if it is in Paula’s ingredients dictionary. I’d love to hear from people who have lipstick allergies. What’s the problem? Maybe some have chemical sunscreens. Not mine!

  • Eraser

    I got the Coral and I like it a lot. The shape of the bullet is the same as Besame’s, so perhaps that’s also a throwback. There was a great chain of discount stores here years ago (sadly gone) and they had the biggest drugstore/discount beauty area I’ve ever seen – they carried the full line of PF and I also never recall a lipstick.

    • Isabella Muse

      it’s weird because the besame one is a little smaller and fits my lip line better. But this is a bit bigger and I found it a little difficult to apply. Me either! I’ve been using them for years and years now but can’t ever recall them doing lipstick!

  • Magenta Wilde

    These are cute. The price is nice, and I like that they have no fragrance. I agree about the tube not swiveling down. I mean it’s nice to see it so you can better see the color, but it’s so easy to chip or dent or slice off. The shape is kind of cute, but it does look like it’d be hard to apply with ease, like your review says.
    Have you spotted any of the eyeshadows yet?

    • Isabella Muse

      it has potential that’s for sure but the packaging and formula is a bit flawed πŸ™ Yes, at walgreens!

  • Kate

    the only place I saw this group was a Walgreens
    I got the coral lipstick which I have not tried yet, the nude shadows were gone, and I passed on the plums as they are not my thing, I ended up ordering the nudes from Amz, you could try there