July 11, 2012

Jill Stuart Patisserie Custard Lip Pot Review & Swatches

The Jill Stuart Patisserie Collection is limited edition collection released for Fall 2012. It’s inspired by a French pastry shop and the packaging, shade names, and scent of the products all bring to mind decadent pastries and desserts.

The Jill Stuart Custard Lip Pots are pretty much spot on for that inspiration as they look like little cups of custard. These were released in five shades and both the colors and product themselves are available for a limited time with this collection.

Take a look!

As with all Jill Stuart products these are housed in gorgeous little jars. Although the difference here is some of Jill Stuart’s elegance is left behind in the packaging and we get a more whimiscal look. The Custard Lip Pots kinda have a Holika Holika vibe to them but they are less cuter and way more elegant. Each “custard” is encased in a clear pot with an off white lid that has a tiny red rhinestone in the center. They do truly remind you of tiny little desserts or even little dollhouse pieces of some sort.

Each of the balms are scented but not flavored with a vanillish fragrance. I’m not really sure how to describe the scent but it’s quite subtle, not overpowering, and is a pleasant enough smell with hints of vanilla and perhaps cake of some sort. No worries though if you’re sensitive as these aren’t flavored.

I’m not sure what you’d want to call them. Tinted lip balm? Tinted lip treatment? Lip creams? It’s really hybrid of a product that acts as a few products in one The consistency reminds me of a densely packed lip cream but has the texture of a heavier lip balm.

Orange Custard

Chocolat Custard

Cherry Custard

Apple Custard

Almond Custard

Almond Custard, Chocolat Custard, Orange Custard, Apple Custard, and Cherry Custard

All the shades are very nude and natural. They kinda remind me of a lip base of sorts which you’d use to lessen the appearance of more pigment lips so a lipstick’s finish is more intense and vibrant. As you know, I don’t pull off nuder lip looks too well so many of the shades gave me a mod finish and I kinda had that evil dead look going on. On much fairer skin than my own I think they’ll make ideal MLBB shades (my lips but better) and enhance the look of paler lips.

I realize they aren’t terribly appealing in a jar packaging and having to apply with fingers and such. Best application is finger application unfortunately so this doesn’t make them travel friendly and of course, bacteria, germs, etc…sadly, we have to overlook these things in beauty sometimes.

For me for the formula wasn’t a terribly big hit. These are a semi-matte finish lip cream of sorts with a bit of tint. I wouldn’t call them sheer but they do have a higher level of pigment that isn’t quite medium coverage. Many of the shades do look very similar once they are on lips or at least they did on my lips so I don’t think you need to indulge in every single shade the way I did.

As I mentioned above, I wasn’t overly impressed with the formula. Creams and matte finishes aren’t my personal loves as I’ve said many times in the past. With a formula that contains apricot oil as well as almond and glucose I thought perhaps they would be more moisturizing than they are. They apply a tad chalky, they look very drying, and they will accentuate drier areas on lips so you’re going to want to apply exfoliate before use and apply a bit of hydrating balm under them for the best look. As the day progresses I feel like they dry out even worst and within an hour in I feel a bit uncomfortable with the formula on my lips. It feels like it’s cracking and starting to look less than smooth.

Needless to say if your lips are dry they won’t be the most flattering lip product nor will they give your lips much needed moisture during the wear. If you already use and are used to semi-matte cream finishes they may just appeal but I personally didn’t love them.

I sadly didn’t feel like I could give these enough love so after a quick swatch with a q-tip I gifted three to my best friend. He’ll make better use and give them the loving home they need.

I did keep Chocolat Custard and Orange Custard for myself. Both shades I really liked as they didn’t give me super pale zombie-like lips and looked very pretty on.

Almond Custard

Orange Custard

Cherry Custard

Overall, you might consider picking one or two of these up if you’re a lover of semi-matte lip creams. The formula won’t appeal to everyone though, I wasn’t so keen myself. I expected more moisture, a slicker feel, and perhaps a little bit more pop.

Sad sigh.

Oh well, we can’t love all the pretty makeup in the world can we?

A friend of mine purchased these for me in Tokyo but the usual suspects will probably get them in stock such as Imomoko.com as well as AlphabeautyUK on E-bay.

They just launched last week in Japan and I suspect they’ll sell out quickly so if you do see them online I urge you to grab them why you can.

Sadly, the Jill Stuart flagship store here in New York does not sell limited releases but if you have a yearning for the brand they do ship within the US and have quite a few pieces from the standard line of cosmetics.

I purchased this item.

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment or follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Bloglovin‘.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • Sai

    This lip pots are so cute. I agree that it could be more moisturized. It’s too dry on my lip if i dun use a lip balm before applying it (my lip ain’t the super dry type).

    Tried this in a JS counter. Color looked good but too dry for my lip. I ended up buying none of them….,good for saving me some money hahahhaha

  • Tiffany Martin

    Muse, first thing I thought when I saw your photos was “WOW your eyes look great!” (:

    I agree that orange custard looks great on you, sad we can’t see the chocolate I bet it looks terrific.

  • Cassie

    MUUUUUSE!!! You are so crazy to have gifted those away (although your friend is very lucky to have received them haha), I think they look GREAT on you!!!
    Seriously, it’s too bad you didn’t like the texture/application/formula of these since they really do look lovely on you… plus I think the packaging is SUPER adorable (I might have to pick some up for myself… bwahahah)!!

    • the Muse

      aw thanks cassie, I’d honestly tuck them into a drawer and never use them so it’s best to gift them ;-D I know Jai will make proper use of ’em! I LOVE the packaging too ;D!

  • Becca @ The Beauty Sample

    Really? I LOVE the look of these on you–and the cute packaging. Some of the Jill Stuart cosmetics are a teensy bit too cutesy for me, but these are adorable. I am also a little obsessed with tinted balms, so this is a major WANT for me!

  • Silvia

    Hey Muse! I just wanna say I love your reviews, they’re so helpful! I was just wondering if you could do a review on Laniege’s Water Sleeping Pack. I know this has nothing to do with your post, but I’ve been eyeballing it lately and I am really curious about what you think because you’re seriously the BEST person to review things. Thanks! 😀

    • the Muse

      aw thanks silvia! so glad you feel that way! I don’t think I have Laniege’s Water Sleeping Pack left to be honest. It really wasn’t on my list to buy again…! so I think you can probably save some $$! 🙂

  • Phyrra

    I think the jars are adorable but I’m so over sticking my fingers in jars.