May 17, 2017

Which Makeup Brand Have You Broken Up With and Why?

The makeup industry is every evolving with new trends, product launches, and many creative and unique ways to capture your a makeup junkie’s attention and eye. There’s a certain pokemon mentality about makeup that has all of clambering to collect every single new release that pops up. Social media creates such a mad frenzy and hype around product launches that you can’t help but be drawn into it.

I’ve come to realize that I really don’t need every single eyeshadow palette that launches. Sure, I still purchase every single new release that launches because I review it on Musings of a Muse but if it was up to me and I wasn’t worried about the blog, I’d probably think twice about a purchase. There are a good deal of quality and formula issues lately and many other aspects that just make you want to break up with your favorite brands. Some of which don’t even have to do with formula but more about morals and how a brand interacts with fans or on social media.

Has any of this influenced your feelings about a certain brand you loved?

Which makeup brands have you broke up with and why?

I’ve broken up with a lot of brands lately! Most of which because of their aggressive social media presence and and constant rotation of badly formulated releases that are over hyped crazily. Tarte, Too Faced, you guys are guilty as charged.

I’ve also semi-broken up with Philosophy. I have so many products I love from Philosophy but ironically I broke up with them a little because they haven’t launched anything new to pique my interest in a long time. They have successfully captured my heart with many of their launches like Philosophy Back to Nurture Deeply Replenishing Beauty Sleep Mask and Miracle Worker Dark Spot Corrector and both are discontinued. Why!?

But I think color cosmetics brands are probably the worst offenders lately. Their releases are too repetitive and there isn’t enough innovation or uniqueness to grab me.

How about you?

Which brands have you broken up with?

Why?

What might tempt you back into buying from them again?

Do share!

About the Muse

Isabella MuseIsabella is just an average everyday geeky girl who doesn’t blend her eyeshadow correctly, wears too much blush, and hopes she never finds her holy grail products because she likes the thrill of the chase so much. Her mission is to bring you super honest reviews on makeup, skincare, fragrance and all things beauty. She’s in no way an expert on the topic and she sure as hell isn’t a super model. But she’s passionate about makeup and is seeking like-minded individuals that like pina coladas, getting caught in the rain, and ones that enjoy spending hundreds of dollars at Sephora without feeling buyer’s remorse. If you’re that person feel free to reach out and leave a comment or follow me on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and Bloglovin‘.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Comments

  • Megan

    Great question, Muse! I have no tolerance for brands that are rude to customers (i.e. Z-palette) or copy-cat brands (i.e. MakeupRevoluion). I also refuse to buy drugstore makeup items that cost more than $12ish dollars. I might as well buy something high-end with a Tester and a good return policy!

    • Isabella Muse

      Very sad when brands are outright rude to customers, there’s no reason for it!

  • Megan

    2nd comment- I forgot to mention that I have broken up with brands that send Youtubers on vacations … TARTE. That’s cheating haha. Finally, I usually don’t buy from brands that exclude Women of Color from their ads/Instagram. There are so many beauty brands nowadays, I think it’s important to only support those that align with your values 🙂

    • Isabella Muse

      I agree about women of color! More diversity please!

    • Sarah

      Good point about vacations! I actually unfollowed Benefit from social media and I’m considering breaking up with them, because I’m kind of annoyed by how they wine and dine the beauty gurus and Influencers, while releasing products that don’t grab my attention. It’s like…why should I support this brand if I don’t mean as much as an influencer? Please focus instead on releasing state of the art products and not spending your entire budget on expensive trips to the Bahamas for a select group of beautiful people.

    • Chelsey

      That is frustrating to me too. Tarte is one of the only brands my skin tolerates, so I won’t break up with them. But I’ve definitely unfollowed most of the youtubers that go on these trips, and I don’t rely on their opinions for determining if I want to purchase something. I also have graduated to a place where I’m in love with 3 eyeshadow palettes and have been able to successfully avoid purchasing all the new ones being thrown at us. If Tarte brings out an amazing quality (on par with the in bloom or either rainforest of the sea circle palettes) green palette, I’ll buy. But for now I’m comfortable using my 3 holy grails.

    • Hayley

      I love how the youtubers always say “this review isn’t sponsored, this video isn’t sponsored”, yet then the brand (tarte, Benefit, etc) sends them on some exotic vacation!! Do they really expect us to believe they’re not promoting that brand’s products?! Come on.

  • Sarah

    Oh boy, for the sake of not sounding bitter I’m going to say Kat Von D and Too Faced because of their social media presence and how they handle their customers. They have been far from professional and I feel it tarnishes the whole brand when the founders behave badly.

    I was considering going back to KVD because I was unable to find an eyeliner as good as her tattoo liner, but then I bought a little jar of Inglot’s AMC Gel Eyeliner and I’m sold. It’s become my HG and I won’t consider going back to KVD.

    • Yelena

      i broke up with KVD too!
      her post about the makeuprevolution palette was too much. i get it you’re annoyed, but you can express yourself in a much more professional and eloquent manner.

      girl, bye!

      if you are looking for a good liquid liner pen, i love love love the eyeko “Eye Do Liquid Eyeliner”. i love it and it lasts all day. i actually prefer it over kvd liquid liner now.
      win win!

      • Colleen

        With you 100% on this Muse. Loved KVD until the whole Makeup Revolution thing. I can appreciate her frustration but I was so disgusted by how it was handled. I got rid of most of my KVD and will not purchase from them in the future.

        • Colleen

          Sorry Muse. Just realized that was not your comment. Definitely agree with Yelena

      • Hayley

        I COMPLETELY agree with you about KVD complaining about the makeup revolution palette. I mean come on, you’re already a super-rich millionaire, are you really going to complain?

    • Megan

      Not to mention TF and KVD “limited edition” products that they release in tiny quantities to create a frenzy and then miraculously bring back huge quantities later. Shady.

      • Isabella Muse

        agreed. I don’t get the newfangled marking of making everyone go crazy over something, it sells out, it’s super limited, etc…etc..and suddenly it comes back and goes on sale!

        • Sarah

          Oh man I hate it when brands do that!! Tarte did that with the Grav3yard Girl collection and I remember sitting in my room waiting for HOURS to order the entire collection and I only ended up checking out with one lipstick! Of course they relaunched it, and I purchased the palette and second lipstick at that time, but then Tarte released it AGAIN and to add insult to injury they marked it down! And I think it’s still on their website as available.

          Tarte, it it wasn’t for the fact that I do love your products I would be so much more angrier! Creating hype and deliberately releasing a small number of LE items is so infuriating, it gives me makeup FOMO, haha!

          • Isabella Muse

            AND IT WENT ON SALE! lol! I was the same! I waited for it to launch and I was able to get it thankfully but after it sold out and came back on sale I was like WTF!

      • amy

        It seems all these brands were trying to copy what MAC had been doing for years, but even MAC seems to be realizing that may not have been the best approach, LOL! Their prices have been lowered, more sales, rolling out less LE collections, etc…

        This practice also bit ABH in the backside; apparently, around the Holidays, the Modern Renaissance palette was nowhere to be found (believe me, I tried!). Around that same time, the warehouse that the palettes were being hoarded, was broken into, and 100,000 or so palettes were stolen… On the plus side, ABH’s decision to hold back the palettes gave me the chance to de cide I really didn’t want it…

    • Susan

      I was never a customer of KvD but she made it a dead cert that I never would be with some of her comments a year or two ago (I won’t post them here because when I’ve done so before I got flamed myself). I would grow, harvest, and grind my own pigments before I bought any of her products. Ever.

      But break up, yeah, Too Faced and I are no longer together. The super-horrible quality of the holiday releases I got — and stupidly did not return, thinking somehow that being stuffed in a drawer would improve them — made me realize that they are all flash and cheap cardboard and cutesy-wootsy lately. There are plenty of other prestige brands out there.

      • amy

        I can only guess what you’re referring to with KvD, and if they are what I think, I absolutely agree (I, too, would rather not state them here). However, I *was* an active, loyal customer from the beginning. I don’t care that her opinions on certain topics differ than mine, but when she makes inferences that are directed at those whose opinions differ from hers, I take offense. Also, with her fan base, she really should back up her statements with specific FACTS, not just hyperbole. Many of them are quite young, and not educated enough to form their own opinions on these particular subjects, and that could be quite dangerous.

        On the other hand, it is an American company, with American employees, so a part of me still wants to support the brand…

    • Ruth

      for an awesome liquid liner, lorac is my hands down favorite! it’s super black, long wearing, water proof, and lasts all day on my combo skin. KVD products have always underwhelmed me and her attitude along with Jerrod at TF, have both turned me off of them and their products.

  • Brian

    Almay. They tout themselves as “Simply American” when they make shades for such a limited amount of skintones. It is like they are trying to exclude people.

      • Susan

        I forgot about Almay. I broke up with them, too, but because the products aren’t very good and it seems like they’re stuck in the ’90s.

    • Chris

      Thank you! Almay was the first company that came to my mind. Foundations that turn orangey after several hours, limited color selections of foundations — no shade between Fair and Light! Eyepencils that you need to practically gouge your eyelid for it to be seen upon application and intense fallout from their eyeshadows even with primer on!

      NYX — tried a retractable lip pencil and it kept breaking off as I used it. Went into the trash.

      Finally, Philosophy — their Supernatural tinted moisturizer before Coty bought it was great. Never had tiny balls of silicone appear on my face when applying it. Most recent tube was terrible– Coty must have changed the formulation. That also got trashed.

  • Pixie

    I’ve broken up with Too Faced because I hate the way the creator acts on social media. Not to mention the fact that the quaility on a lot of their products has GREATLY decreased.
    I’ve also been broken up with Jeffree Star for some time because he’s a racist.

  • Sheree

    Clinique. I worked for them for YEARS, but I’m sorry, half their products just don’t do anything at all.

    • Isabella Muse

      I have to sadly agree. When they do good skincare, they do it well but a majority of their products don’t work for me at all!

    • Carol G

      Hey, I worked for them as well and even when I did I knew their cosmetics products were subpar. Their skincare is at least decent. But when they started rolling out 9,10,11 new skincare products every 3-4 months I finally had enough. Like we were supposed to get people to buy all this new crap when Clinique shoves their beloved 3-step system down our throats at every class. It was getting ridiculous. Their mascara is horrible. They did not have a matte bronzer. Their eyeliners lasted a few weeks at $17 a pop. I could go on and on. So yeah, I will never purchase another Clinique product as long as I live.

  • Carolina

    Philosophy used to be one of my favorites too. My Philosophy purchases have really dwindled over the last two years. It seems like the website has become a secondary market for what they don’t sell on QVC. Also, they used to have better deals on items and/or shipping.

    Part of it may be that I did go overboard with 3-in-1 gels and have still to go through my stash. However, it does seem like the fun, innovative ideas have turned into rehashes of things like Purity or When Hope is Not Enough. Still hope that the “love” can be rekindled one day with this brand.

    • Isabella Muse

      I couldn’t agree more. I don’t understand what happened to them! I always hope they’ll do something new because I really like their skincare but a lot of it is repromoted, I’d love to see something brand new!

    • Andi

      I think once Cristina Carlye (I think that was her last name) sold the company to Coty it was all downhill for Philosophy. Real Purity and Hope in a Jar do nothing for me

  • Christina D.

    I’ve been buying makeup for so many years, I’ve broken up with numerous brands:
    – Anything drugstore and/or Made in China;
    – By Terry (possibly the absolute worst experience I have had with eyeshadows ever, especially considering the ridiculous price point);
    – YSL;
    – Dior;
    – Borghese;
    – Lancome (except Lancome’s eye makeup remover which is the best IMO);
    – Estee Lauder;
    – Bobbi Brown;
    – Trish McEvoy;
    – Clinique;
    – MAC (except for the 15 pan palettes);
    – Tarte (except for Rainforest palettes);
    – TooFaced (except for pencil eyeliners) – admittedly, more like “in the process of dumping them”� since I got sucked in by the Romantic Nudes palette after passing on TF releases for months.
    I’m sure there’s a few more but you get the idea.

    • MerryRower

      I’ve been a make-up buyer for many a year as well. I even became a cosmetics SA at Macy’s (back when it was a nice store) as a teen so I could play at work, and get the discount. I have broken up with quite a few brands too, too many to detail again, as they are getting their due here. Yet there are a few which deserve a special shout-out, the perpetrators who no longer get my adoration, thus

      THE HALL OF SHAME
      (deserved the dumping)

      Urban Decay/TooFaced/Tarte/MAC/Stila/SmashBox
      boring, ugly, repetitious, mediocre quality

      Bobbi Brown/Clinique/Estee Lauder
      dumbed down, uneven quality, not worth the time

      Tom Ford/By Terry
      un-earned price point, faux luxury, poor performance

      ON THE VERGE
      (I spend time with these but then hate myself)

      Nars
      Hourglass
      YSL
      Armani
      Suratt

      EARNING A SECOND CHANCE
      (there’s something about each that has me interested again)

      Lancome
      Shiseido

      GOING STRONG

      Dior
      Trish McEvoy
      Laura Mercier
      Cle de Peau

      CURRENT FLIRTATIONS

      Marc Jacobs
      Kosas
      Bite Beauty

      Reading all this, I realize my cosmetics love life is a tele novella!

  • M. P.

    Charlotte Tilbury! I used to love that brand, but all the recent releases have been terrible! Plus, she’s been fawning over the Kardashians, which has really changed my opinion of the brand. I don’t buy make up made for porn stars.

    • Leih

      I love this comment! Down with Kardashians and making up our faces to be unrecognizable!

  • Susan

    Too Faced! I still like some of their classic products but not the newer releases. I haven’t bought anything more recent than the Chocolate Bar palette. It’s a combo of too many mediocre releases and the social media/professionalism issue.

  • chibi639

    I’ve broken up with the drugstore. I can’t be the only one who has noticed that prices aren’t quite so low with drugstore brands anymore. Base products can reach into the $12-15 range. And no testers! Why!? I did once (ONCE) come across a L’Oreal display that did have testers for their True Match display. I’m wondering if it was a dream now….

    Also, mid-range prestige brands (Tarte, TF, UD, KVD as others have mentioned) have been pumping out LE releases like crazy in the past few years and I’m just tired. I feel like it’s sensory overload and the quality tends to not be there. The packaging may be shiny but the variety is also stale. No one needs another nude palette or rose gold palette or unicorn palette….. Let’s not lie to ourselves. 99% us will never finish using our stash of uber shimmery magical eye shadow no matter how lovely it looks in the pan.

    I’ve found I’m sticking to my tried and true staple products and diligently trying to work through my existing stash. It’s been two months (proud of myself here) since I’ve been tempted to buy anything new. When every brand tries to tout their new releases as special and must have, they all come across as not actually that special….

    • Isabella Muse

      I haven’t broken up with drugstore makeup but I agree. It’s very very very expensive! The price range is nearly at a mid-range brand for drugstore makeup!

  • Wingadings

    I have yet to break up with a make up brand. Though there are brands I won’t purchase (even though some of theur products seem good or perfectly covetable) from. KVD keeps making nasty comments online. Same with Jeffree Star. They have been rude to customer’s and just generally mean. I broke up with clinique and then Origins because their eye creams have burned the skin around my eyes badly (I like red eye shadows but my goal isn’t to look like a sick red panda). And I stopped buying Dove because all their stuff- minus their unscented bar- make me sneeze uncontrollably.

    I try not to buy products that test on animals and use animal products. Sooo I’ve never bought any Covergirl products (though their new Coverboy and his racism was a huge turnoff).

  • PDO

    Yeah it’s kind of hard to back a brand that has is aggressive on social media or you’ve “heard” does bad things, but if we are really going to judge a beauty brand or beauty company based on this, are we going to start doing background checks on every single thing we buy. I’m sure we all currently buy something from a company that has a less than stellar moral record.

    I don’t know… just a thought

    • Jeanine

      I could not agree more! With that said, my line is racism . I can’t handle that EVER!

  • Kimmwc03

    I can only honestly say that I’ve broken up with Lime Crime and Jeffree Star. I haven’t bought as much TF and KVD lately (but I’m not longer a fan of the brands and have unfollowed them on social media).

    I’ve also severely cut back on buying drugstore due to the rising prices.

  • Lisa I

    I stopped buying Bobbi brown when they changed the pot blushes to about half the amount but the same high price. Just smacks of greed. Clinique has been disappointing the past few years, used to be my go to brand for skincare.

  • Courtney

    Tarte , for sure , for the same reasoning others have mentioned ; sending influencers on these grandiose trips to exotic islands. Yep, sorry , I’m not gonna contribute to paying for that nonsense. Too Faced because their packaging is too cute for me; it was cook when I was 21ish in age …. I now tend to Love packaging from hourglass, marc jacobs, charlotte tilbury as an example.. I tend to shy away from brands that now use YouTubers to collab with . It’s overkill now .

    • Megan

      I completely agree. I stopped buying from brands that rely on Collabs and packaging to sell product.

    • Sarah B.

      I agree on the over saturation of youtube people. I am sick of seeing these girls with WAY too much make up getting free product/trips. You can’t tell if it’s a good product or just them selling the brand because they receive free stuff.

  • lizzie

    Like most people that visit your blog I’ve tried a plethora of brands. Break up? I would say there are far too many to list but alternatively the brands that have survived all the declutter and are my tried and true staples
    Loreal
    Wet n Wild
    Maybeline for their mascara’s and eyeliner
    Hourglass ambient blushes and powders
    Armani for their foundations
    Tom Ford their eye shadows I use coco mirage daily
    Kevyn Aucoin sensual skin enhancer as concealer, eye brow pencil
    Nars
    Marc Jacobs and Chanel for eyeliners
    I just keep it super simple now a days and yes I’ve tried all the others Bare Minerals, Tarte, Too Face, It Cosmetics, By Terry, Cle de Peau, Shisedo, Guerlain, Sisley,….Rimmel, Milani…..etc.

  • Andi

    For me it’s not the social media, since I’m not much into all of it, it’s more so the overall quality that’s made me stop buying brands. I haven’t bought Tarte, TF, or Benefit in a long time. I’ve also noticed that IT seems to be declining a bit too so they may be on their way out of my bag.

  • kjh

    Never started lime crime or jeffo, and won’t. Done with tf, except snow bunny. Done with Fresh due to complete change in direction. Their choose 4 shadows were pissah and their red lipsticks were all that! Have been off Dior due to unimpressed and Chanel, due to price, but that could change. Outgrew Clinique until cheek pops. Lauder has become more relevant, but haven’t been there in years. Also not a big fan of their corporate reach and acquisition. Doubt they will improve tf at all, and they are messing with TF. Haven’t bought any Tarte in years: the holiday PRC bit and the fact that they (and the rest of the world) do not disclose. Tarte also bored me for years, with the warm browns, pinks, and corals. They channeled 180 from my color preferences. I had all the Tarte I liked. The ROTS lips might draw me. BUT, not buying does not mean not scoping out! Social media stuff, aside from the unless-you-were-born-under-a-rock type, like fawning and vacationing the YTers and influencers, and the kvd/js fight, …no influence at all. I follow myself only and eschew SM, except 2 truthful blogs and googling swatches. TOFTS. (too old for……)

  • blee

    The Balm. They sent me a eye shadow pallet unwrapped with some ones finger prints in it. The CS was so bad I never bought from them again. Haven’t missed them at all. 😀

  • Sk

    KVD for me. It frustrates me because I love the type of products she puts out and the quality seems consistent. BUT, the way she named a certain lipsticks few years ago and the way she handled it hurt me so profoundly as an autistic person and I can never get over it even if she apologize about it (which I think she hasn’t really). Also the way she called people who buy MUR as “cheap” and how her fans said make more money if you want to buy good makeup…just shows how some people take for granted their financial status. For some MUR can be a luxury item.

  • Dominique !

    Since I’m a teacher, and basically live on a peasant salary , Im very careful about where I put my money. So far, I’ve broken up with :
    -Too faced (shitty formulas & poor customer service)
    -MAC (way too expensive here in Montreal)
    -Revlon (they’re the absolute worst with powdered stuff ; and I don’t get behind racist comments)
    -L’Oreal (Mind you, their factory is less than 3 miles from my home, and they still charge 30$ CAD for their basic nude palette)
    -Garnier (I’ll buy the real Korean stuff for half the price)
    -Benefit (simply overpriced)

    I’m now buying Indie (like juvias place that is AMAZING) or more local. The exchange rate is killing me, and I don’t see why I wouldn’t encourage a good brand with much more honesty behind their practices!

  • Isa

    I haven’t really broken up with a brand as such, because the brands I find objectionable enough to boycott, I actually don’t have anything from. I will never buy Jeffree Star, Lime Crime or Morphe. I think at this point I can safely say that I won’t be buying anything that is a collab with beauty gurus.

    Oh hey, now that I think about it, I do have something from a brand I will never buy anything from again. Z-palette. After that fiasco with the depotting machine thing, I’ve made the switch to buying empty magnetic palettes from Nars instead. Believe it or not, where I’m at, they are actually cheaper than Z-palettes and also larger.

    I’m giving the side-eye to Tarte and Benefit for those PR trips and to Too Faced for their unprofessional behaviour. I don’t actually care what they supposedly did to Nikkie Tutorials because the girl has a lawyer and no Youtuber can actually be coerced into signing a contract. But when Too Faced started slinging mud at Tarte and other brands, that was unnesccessary and so high-school. That’s how I would characterize how a lot of these companies are behaving these days. It’s like watching mean girl teenagers having a catfight over social media.

  • Cheryl

    The only companies that I will categorically not buy from are those that test on animals. That said, I don’t buy any new product releases anymore until I have seen reviews by the few people whose opinions I trust (you, Isabella, are one of those people). I do admittedly make exceptions for QVC TSVs if they are from a brand I know that has demonstrated consistency in thenquality of their products. other than that, if a product gets good reviews, I will head to Ulta to try those that are available. Since I do not have a nearby Sephora, I will rarely buy anything exclusively sold there absent consistent glowing reviews from all 4 of my trusted “sources”!

  • Heidi

    Megan made a good point about manners. I also don’t like being witness to social media feuds. On one hand it seems a childish and rude way to hash out a debate in public, and on another hand I suspect it’s done to draw up attention.
    I don’t know if I’ve broken up with any brands entirely but there are a lot I steer away from or purchase extremely rarely for one reason or another.
    I still buy drug store but I’m not crazy about how they’re jacking up prices. Especially when a lot of new items land in drug stores first and tend to be marked up considerably there. I don’t like paying $12 or more for a foundation at the corner drug store when I know it’s cheaper — if I can find it — elsewhere.
    I tend to avoid brands that heavily fragrance their products. I break out badly from perfumed formulas and still bear scars of past breakouts, so some brands I’m leery of at best.
    I also avoid brands that don’t suit my aesthetic. Mainly if it’s a spokeperson or someone at the brand if they look like they’re promoting makeup as a way to mask and redraw someone’s face instead of enhance what someone already has, I get turned off by that. If someone likes it, fine, buy it, enjoy it, but I’m voting with my dollar there and I don’t want to support a brand that works with people who aim to look like plastic.

  • Kgirl

    Tarte and I officially split when they changed their smooth operator tinted moisturizer formula to a “BB Cream” complete with a pound of shimmer. It was my HG, they are still not forgiven. Lol

  • sleepybird

    I have almost completely broken up with drugstore makeup. The prices are getting ridiculous. I just wait for occasional “hot buy” items at Ulta or for whatever UD I have been lusting after to hit their sale section. Why pay 10 bucks for a substandard drugstore eyeliner when waiting patiently got me the Ocho Loco 2 release for what worked out to be around $3.00 a piece for full size 24/7 liners? I love UD but only pay full price for some core items. I stalk the sale page and so scored the Smoked, Electric, Deluxe Shadow and Naked on the Run palettes all for about
    50% off. Since drugstore shadows can often be more when priced per ounce than even regular priced mid-range brands I get much more for my money this way. The only drugstore brand I will still buy is Jordana…. They have some amazing products and super affordable.

  • Michelle

    Gotta agree with so many on here about Too Faced and Tarte. I find it absolutely obnoxious the PR stuff. These over-the-top PR kits to attract the YouTubers to open them on camera does not “entice” me in the slightest. It repulses me. That is no way to attract customers. I find myself really going for brands that are not YouTube Famous and have had a solid product line for decades….. Chanel, Loreal, Lancome, Dior, Estee Lauder, Nars. This also helps with the dreaded elimination of a product that you love. These brands have kept their staple products for decades and I don’t have to worry about “discontinued” on something I love.

  • Carrie

    I made a New Year’s Resolution this year to break-up with any and all companies that still test on animals. I also broke-up with companies that say they are against animal testing, but still sell in China knowing their products will, in fact be tested on animals.
    The funny thing is, by limiting or narrowing the companies I can buy from I’ve actually ended up curating a small bag full of HG products that have given me a new, easy, pretty look! I’ve never gotten so many compliments since I started using basically only IT cosmetics and Julep!
    I also have found that I have essentially stripped down my skin care to only Julep products and my 43 year old skin has never looked so good! I had some moles removed from my face recently and the Dermatologist couldn’t believe I was 43! Made my day!
    The other major benefit has been losing so much clutter in my life. My teen and pre-teen nieces loved getting bags full of things to play with too!

  • Yen

    I haven’t broken up with any brands as of yet. I tend to buy all my makeup from a bunch of different brands based on their quality. There aren’t any brands that I purchase mainly from. All these LE releases from makeup companies actually make me not want to buy anything. I feel nothing is innovative or creative anymore. I yawn every time I walk into Sephora.

    I read a lot of comments mentioning Too Faced and KVD. I’ve never bought anything from TF since the quality of the products don’t particularly wow me. I love cute packaging, but packaging alone won’t get me to purchase an item. I have heard that the melted liquified long wearing lipsticks are good, but I usually don’t wear lip products with that consistency.

    The only KVD products I ever bought would be the tattoo liner and studded kiss lipstick in Adora. I freakin love Adora and haven’t found anything to be similar. I love the tattoo liner and haven’t been able to find a readily available, easy to find, eye liner with a brush tip like KVD. Eyeliner is one of the things I don’t buy online. I think my instant gratification mindset makes me want to buy and use it asap. As rude as KVD can be, I’m in love with the calligraphy brush on her eyeliner.

  • Jonnie

    I haven’t really broken up with any, but being in my late 40s I’m not on social media as much either. But I hate that the quality of certain brands are always so questionable. Sometimes I love Bobbi Brown and It Cosmetics, and then sometimes their eyeshadows have no pigmentation. And why does every model have to be 18? I would love to see some models my age wearing products, but I have a feeling that isn’t going to happen anytime soon! I’ve been thinking about re-visiting some very old lines like Elizabeth Arden and Merle Norman???

    • Heidi

      I’m 44 and agree, Jonnie. I’d like to see women closer to my age, or in the are case an older model is used, please don’t photoshop decades off her face. Do a before and after using the product. I don’t expect a miracle and to look like I’m 22 again, but hey, show me this product can make me look refreshed or something. One thing I do like about L’Oreal, though I don’t like every product they have, but they do have spokeswomen of different ages and they show a lot of diversity. Some ad they ran a month or two ago in a couple magazines showed their foundation offerings with a bunch of models, from the palest of the pale to nearly blue-black skin. Seeing that, I thought, yes, I have no problem buying that foundation again. (Plus I like it a lot…)

      I’m annoyed with a lot of products that are wildly uneven. For example, some time back I bought a couple Kat Von D lipsticks. BauHau5 performs like a champ. It applies evenly, wears evenly and has great pigmentation. I also bought Motorhead, and that settled in lip lines and was plain awful. How can one shade in the same line work so well while others suck? Where’s the quality control?

  • Amber G.

    Well, I agree with most of the girls here. There are several companies that I’ve completely parted ways with- Jeffree Star being the big one. Second place collectively goes to all the companies putting out collabs with YouTubers/Influensers. I’m SOOOO over it. I’ve definitely gotten sucked in to a few of these and feel particularly burned by the poor quality of the NIKKIETUTORIALS palette.
    I also have heaps of UD Naked this-and-that and Vice palettes galore, so I haven’t been returning their calls either- LOL
    Breaking up is hard to do, they say…in this case, it was pretty easy!

  • reen

    Lots of very interesting comments in this section here. And a very good question Muse!
    I tend to find overly sexualized marketing unappealing to me. I don’t appreciate shade names such as “orgasm” or “deep throat” and would much rather prefer to see companies empower women with more positivity in every way possible. Lindy Tsang (known as Bubzbeaty on youtube) released an eyeshadow pallete with very inspiration shadow color names, such as “grateful” “kind” “inspired” “optimistic”….to me, that is extremely appealing….lets me start the day looking at positive words, even as i apple makeup and get ready for the day!

    I also tend to stay away from makeup lines such as Kylie Jenner products. Thats a whole other story…. 🙂

    • Heidi

      Good points. I’m not too bothered by some names, including Orgasm, or if there was something called Afterglow, okay, fine, but Underage Red, Call Girl, and others… please, no. Enough young women and girls are victims.

  • Iris

    Mawkins. I used to love their drugstore selection in my tweens. They then switched to all items being made in Canada.

    Any brand which insults their customers or has a horrible attitude (Z-Palette and Two Faced are ones which comes to mind), ones which support organizations or causes I don’t agree with (a certain indie one which donated to PETA).

    • Iris

      *oops, my writing cut off. Should’ve said: Mawkins switched from all items being made in Canada and USA to everything being made in China.

  • Jackie P

    I broke up with Benefit years ago due to their crappy hiring practices. They are discriminatory in who they hire based on looks. If you don’t fit that tattoo’d rockabilly style they won’t call you back, even though they have you do a 4 hour working interview. This was probably 10 years ago, but I was the only person who knew their products and the only person to sell an item during said “interview” aka free labor. However they only hired the tattoo’d applicants and didn’t bother to call people back to tell them thank you but we’re going in a different direction.

    I’ve also all but broken up with Dior… Every time I like something of theirs they discontinue it, and non of their new eye shadows etc. have been exciting me. MAC doesn’t excite me anymore either but they have some basics I’ll never give up.

    What annoys me the most is when brands put out a “new” palette only for 3-4 of the colors to be “re-releases” or re-named old colors. That’s just pure laziness!!

  • jenaralee

    Since it seems like the general consensus is that no one approves of these luxury trips for influencers, I started thinking about the numbers…
    If you guess the average sale on Tarte’s website is $50 (i’m sure that’s being conservative) then a 20% off sale on that is $10.00

    If Tarte takes 20 influencers on a trip at a cost of $5k each (again, conservative, this doesn’t even include all the Tarte employees that go…) then your total investment is about $100,000.00

    So for the same cost of that trip, 10,000 (TEN FREAKING THOUSAND) Tarte customers could have shopped a sale for 20%.

    I don’t know about you, but a 20% off sale seems more like a win-win. Customers are happy, and ensures more follow-up sales, and Tarte makes tons of money on the sale.
    What, exactly, is the return on investment for a stupid influencer trip?

    BYE, Tarte!

    (and yes, I’m fully aware that this long, drawn-out comment reads like a 3rd grade math problem.) “If a train leaves Boston at 9am…”

  • Brandy

    Wow. So many people hate Clinique. I just discovered a few of the products in their Moisture Surge line (spray, mask, and concentrate) work really well for my rosacea.
    I haven’t been able to break up with a lot of prestige brands yet mostly due to the fact that I haven’t tried much. I get overwhelmed by all the choices, and I’ve had to return a few products that an Ulta or Sephora associate has helped me pick out because I was underwhelmed by them. I definitely will never try KVD products due to her poor attitude.
    As far as drugstore brands, I no longer buy Revlon or Almay (exception being a few lip products) because the quality has been bad.

  • Christina

    Hmmm…I haven’t really broken up with any specific brand that I’ve bought from, but these days I rarely buy anything from Tarte, IT or Lorac.

  • genevieve

    The comments that readers have written above all points of view that I find myself agreeing with.
    Here in Aus. ‘drugstore’ prices are HUGE – $37 for a bottle of Revlon Colourstay foundation!

    Brands I have broken up with:
    Revlon – very poor quality for the price
    L’Oreal – their foundations are far too yellow for me and I don’t like their eyeshadows
    Nars: Obnoxious names for their products – quite offensive and rude really
    Lancome: Expensive and poor quality eye shadows of the past few years.
    Dior: As above.

    Brands I won’t buy from:
    Kat Von D
    Tarte
    Too Faced
    Lime Crime
    Gerard Cosmetics
    Napolean Perdis – average quality for a big price…..
    All of the above have problems with quality, rants on social media etc. Not interested.

    Brands that are on the edge of losing my custom
    Urban Decay – some really ordinary products of late and dodgy names
    Estee Lauder – very expensive products.

    A great question Isabella.

  • Hannah Kanter

    I’ve broken up with most drugstore brands because I don’t like their animal testing policies. Almay got really boring, though I used to love their shade matching foundation.

    Can someone explain the tarte “influencer” thing to me? I like a lot of their cosmetics but some of their stuff is kind of overhyped/overrated (I loved the comment about 99% of us not finishing a shimmery eyeshadow).

  • Helen

    Charlotte Tilbury 100%
    Not only do they insist on peddling the total LIE that PT is “universally flattering” , they’re just a generally disingenuous and tacky organisation. Yukky.